Composite Toe vs. Steel Toe Boots

Composite toe and steel-toe boots have long been trusted friends in the industrial and construction fields. Actually, steel toe working boots and composite toe working boots have also increased in popularity, even for people who don’t work in the construction industry.

Both were designed to ensure that the wearer of the boot remains safe and comfortable while working all day. While there are a number of different brands that sell composite-toe boots and steel-toe boots, the first decision you have to make is which composition you are going with.

So which is better? It actually depends on the wearer’s preferences, but also largely on the type of industry. Both have their own characteristics that offer benefits and protection.

Why should you choose steel toe work boots?

Steel-toe work boots are the classic work buddies. Trusted by workers for decades, they remain popular because they give the maximum protection for your toes. Made from tough steel, they can protect your toes from any falling object.

They give you great protection even from hazards brought by equipment such as chainsaws. Steel-toe boots also do a great job when it comes to protecting you from other possible injuries such as punctures and falling objects.

While steel-toe boots are also heavier and can be uncomfortable during the first few wears, they are also more affordable and more resilient compared to composite-toe boots.  When you want moderate to heavy protection, steel-toe working boots are definitely the way to go. They offer great protection while also being comfortable enough to walk in the whole day.

Another thing to watch out for, it that steel-toe work boots set off metal detectors and this is a slight inconvenience. Steel toe boots also have insulation, but they can be less warm during cold temperatures.

Why should you go for composite toe work boots?

Newer than the steel-toe work boots, composite toe boots are lighter in weight, and they are also more comfortable. They are made from plastic and Kevlar.

The materials used to make composite-toe boots are not as strong as those used in steel-toe boots, so composite-toe boots make up for it by becoming thicker. However, they offer only low to moderate levels of protection.

Though this used to limit the styles available, especially for women, they now have the new carbon safety fiber safety toes, which are thinner. Because of the construction used to create composite-toe boots, they also tend to cost more.

Basically, if you need just a moderate amount of protection from hazards, composite-toe work boots will work for you. While they can’t take as much impact as a steel-toe boot can, composite toe boots will work great in extremely high or low temperatures. Too much weight or pressure can cause a composite-toe boot to crack or shatter, but at least they won’t heat up like a steel toe would.

Composite-toe shoes will not set off any metal detectors because they are non-metallic. So security personnel and airport workers can use these boots because they constantly pass through a number of detectors during the day.

Who wins?

Well, the wearer of the boots is actually the real winner. Whether you choose one over the other, or decide to get both, you are backed up by research.

In the end, it’s you who will decide which one is better for you. Will you walk through detectors more than a few times? Is the equipment heavy? How much protection do your toes need? And of course, which shoe are you most comfortable in?

In order to decide, observing your workmates, asking around the workplace, or even asking your supervisor could largely impact the decision you are going to make. More experienced workers would also likely have an experienced opinion.

Once you have decided which steel toe shoe to go with, the next step is to research which brand caters to your preferences and needs.